Twelve years after its original broadcast, Doctor Who’s 2014 episode “The Caretaker” is increasingly regarded by fans as the moment the show’s most unhinged Doctor was revealed at his ugliest — not through a monster of the week, but through a quiet, uncomfortable character drama pitting the Twelfth Doctor against Clara Oswald’s boyfriend, Danny Pink. Aired on BBC One in 2014, the episode follows the Doctor (Peter Capaldi) as he goes undercover as a janitor at Coal Hill School, where Clara (Jenna Coleman) teaches, in pursuit of an alien robot known as the Skovox Blitzer. Yet as Whovians reflect on the series’ 2005-to-2025 run, the true weight of the episode lies in how it frames the Doctor’s own hypocrisy — and how he treats a man who mirrors the very violence he claims to abhor.
A Killer Robot That Isn’t the Point
On the surface, “The Caretaker” is a forgettable entry in the show’s catalog. The Skovox Blitzer, a menacing alien robot capable of destroying Earth, provides the episode’s central threat and plenty of cool-factor spectacle. But writer Gareth Roberts deliberately sidelines the monster, choosing instead to center the story on the collision between Clara’s two very different lives: her ordinary existence as an English teacher dating fellow teacher Danny, and her extraordinary adventures across time and space with the Doctor. When those two worlds finally converge in this episode, the result is deliberately uncomfortable for everyone involved — including the Doctor himself.
The Doctor at His Most Ugly
From his introduction in season 8, the Twelfth Doctor has established himself as no-nonsense and critical — a sharp departure from the sentimental, whimsical alien Clara was accustomed to under the Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith). That attitude reaches its peak in “The Caretaker,” where the Doctor confronts Danny, a former soldier he is entirely unable to see as anything but a soldier. Dismissing his intelligence and referring to him as “a PE teacher” — presumably because he doesn’t believe Danny is clever enough to teach mathematics — the Doctor’s contempt deepens when he realizes Clara is dating him at all. Earlier in the episode, the Doctor had assumed Clara’s romantic interest was Adrian, a fellow teacher who resembles his previous incarnation, the Eleventh Doctor, with his bow tie and fancy hair, and who appears more emotionally stable thanks to his role as an educator.
Roberts plays the Adrian-versus-Danny misunderstanding for laughs, and it’s genuinely funny to watch an otherwise brilliant character trip up this way. But it also offers a fascinating window into the Doctor’s psyche — particularly how he interprets Clara’s feelings toward him. Whovians will recall that in season 8’s first episode, the Doctor accused Clara of not truly “seeing” him and of wanting Eleven back. Clara’s pursuit of a relationship with someone resembling his past self therefore reads as both an ego boost and confirmation that the Doctor was right about her love for his predecessor. When she ends up with Danny instead, the Doctor’s entire perspective on Clara and their relationship shatters.
“The man who abhors violence, never carrying a gun, but this is the truth, Doctor: You take ordinary people and fashion them into weapons… behold your Children of Time, transformed into murderers.”
Davros, season 4 finale
That line of reasoning traces back to Davros, the creator of the Daleks and the Doctor’s most hated enemy, who tells the Time Lord in the season 4 finale. To the Doctor, whoever Clara dates reflects him — and Danny becomes a dark mirror. Despite the Time Lord’s repeated proclamations that he abhors violence, it has shaped his entire existence, down to an iteration known as the War Doctor. Clara, who knows Danny used to be a soldier and still loves him, becomes the audience’s perfect lampshade for the similarities between the two men. Unintentionally, she finds herself caught between the two most important men in her life — and, much to their chagrin, they turn out to be more alike than either of them admits.
When Danny asks Clara whether she loves the Doctor, she says she does but “not in that way,” and he immediately challenges her to explain what she means — a question she finds difficult to answer. The Doctor and Danny are so similar that the Doctor’s treatment of Danny is hard to watch, especially given that the Time Lord has made plenty of friends who are soldiers over the years, including within active military organizations like UNIT. Even so, the episode serves as a poignant reminder that, for all the good the Doctor does, he can have an ugly — even monstrous — side.
Looking Ahead
The Doctor and Danny’s relationship isn’t resolved by the time “The Caretaker” ends, but they reach a grudging understanding, united by their mutual love for Clara and the terrible things they’ve both done — and regret. Ultimately, Gareth Roberts shows that despite all the good the Doctor accomplishes, he is also jealous, petty, and often unwilling to face these darker sides of himself until forced to. That’s precisely what makes the Time Lord such a compelling protagonist in the first place — because, really, who wants a perfect hero?
Doctor Who’s 2005 to 2025 seasons are available to buy via Amazon or Apple. They can also be streamed via AMC+. You can watch the two most recent seasons and some specials on Disney Plus.
1 comment