Welcome to a new era of comic book reviews here at IGN! To kick things off, we dove headfirst into Oni Press’ ambitious reboot of the Archie universe. We’re tackling all three series with our initial impressions, ready to deliver verdicts and help you decide which (if any) are worth your time this fall.
Archie #1: A Familiar Face in a New Era
[[MEDIA_0: Caption: Fábio Moon’s art brings a fresh, dynamic feel to the classic Archie characters.]]
If you’re looking for a safe and familiar entry point into this rebooted Archieverse, then “Archie #1” is likely your best bet. It’s essentially a reimagining of the classic series, but perhaps not as radical a departure as some might expect. While the term “reimagined” might be a bit generous, the new Archie does offer a fresh coat of paint on the long-running franchise.
The key selling point for many was the involvement of Casanova and Daytripper artist Fábio Moon. His work is undeniably fantastic, bringing a postmodern visual touch to Riverdale. Moon’s dynamic pages expertly capture the hectic nature of Archie’s day. The art meshes well with Jason Wordie’s colors, adding depth and texture.
The story introduces us to a film festival at Riverdale High, where Archie juggles helping friends while pursuing his own idea. This allows writer Ben H. Winters and artist Moon to quickly introduce the supporting cast and their relationships with Archie. However, the story lacks depth. It’s fun and lighthearted, but doesn’t strive for anything beyond a classic Archie adventure. Even giving this script to an artist like Dan Parent could easily place it in a grocery store checkout lane Archie Double Digest. I was hoping for something more experimental or serialized. For now, the “New Riverdale” reboot still holds the crown for reinventing Archie for the 21st century.
The backup story featuring Jughead hints at more ambitious storytelling to come, digging deeper into his psychology. Hopefully, this is a sign of things to come.
Score: 7
Sabrina the Teenage Witch #1: A Spellbinding Debut
[[MEDIA_1: Caption: Kano’s art perfectly balances the wholesome roots of Sabrina with a touch of darkness.]]
While “Archie #1” plays it safe, “Sabrina the Teenage Witch #1” is easily the most satisfying debut. It strikes a perfect balance between honoring the franchise’s all-ages roots and embracing its new possibilities.
Similar to “Archie #1,” this issue throws us into Sabrina’s life at a chaotic time: she’s just discovered her magical abilities and is trying to juggle them with high school fun. Writer Corinna Bechko wisely skips the origin story, jumping right into what comes next.
The dynamic between Sabrina and her cat Salem steals the show. Salem is hilarious as he bickers with his befuddled owner. Overall, Sabrina is very likable, torn between high school life and the darker world that’s opened before her.
Kano’s art complements the lighthearted but slightly sinister vibe of the script perfectly. The series expertly toes the line between honoring the past and establishing its own unique feel. Kano’s facial work is wonderfully expressive, giving each character a welcome burst of personality. This is a book to keep an eye on.
Score: 9
Archie in Hell #1: A Descent into Darkness
[[MEDIA_2: Caption: Tyler Crook’s art blends the classic Archie aesthetic with a dark, twisted vibe.]]
For those seeking a more subversive take on Archie, “Archie in Hell” is the spiritual successor to Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa and Francesco Francavilla’s “Afterlife with Archie.” Hopefully, this one avoids the shipping issues that plagued its predecessor.
The biggest selling point is the infusion of supernatural horror into the Archie universe. However, issue #1 is a slow burn, taking its time to transition from a standard Archie adventure to something darker and more grotesque. While fun, it lacks the immediate impact of “Afterlife with Archie.”
Artist Tyler Crook expertly blends the classic Archie aesthetic with a dark, twisted vibe. Early on, you can almost trick yourself into thinking you’re reading a regular Archie comic, only to be reminded otherwise by the black magic and ritualistic sacrifices. This series holds plenty of potential, but much rides on the final page twist.
Score: 6
Source: IGN Gaming
Comments
Be the first to comment.